American Mussar

21st century Jewish spiritual practice for an authentic and meaningful life

  • About
    • About Greg Marcus
    • Frequently Asked Questions – American Mussar FAQ
    • Blog
    • Sign Up For the American Mussar Newsletter
    • Contact
    • Mantra Cards
      • Cart
  • Personal Transformation
  • Get Closer To Judaism
  • Empower Your Institution
  • Soul Trait Quiz
  • Book
    • Mussar Books

Why Gratitude is Not Enough This Thanksgiving: A Mussar Perspective

November 27, 2019 By Greg Marcus 1 Comment

gratitude is not enough
Gratitude helps us recognize abundance, and to be Generous

“My son was volunteering at a homeless shelter. In walked one of his high school classmates. I’m proud that he ran into the kitchen and helped there so his classmate would not see him.”

A friend told me that story, right here in the San Francisco Bay Area, one of the most wealthy areas in the world. Everywhere we see earth shaking companies like Google, Facebook, Twitter and Apple. The downside of this wealth is astronomically high real estate prices. But that alone does not account for the high level of homelessness. People all over the country are struggling with financial and food insecurity, even as some of us become more financially secure.
While Thanksgiving is a holiday that is rightly associated with being grateful, Gratitude is not enough for those who practice Mussar. Gratitude bring confidence and peace of mind. When we recognize the richness of what we have, we have an opportunity to See those with less, and to fully recognize their humanity. It would be a shame if we kept the abundance we are feeling for ourselves. 
Rabbi Ira Stone defines Mussar as learning to bear the burden of the other. We don’t do this spiritual practice for ourselves, but to help us show up for other people. Judaism teaches that everyone should give charity (Tzedakah), even those who receive Tzedakah. If giving would endanger one’s life, then we are asked to give words of comfort.
For whatever reason, I don’t volunteer in shelters or soup kitchens, although I always contribute to the food drive. I’m looking for ideas on how else I can be Generous. I’d love to hear from you. What do you do to be Generous?
You might also like my post from last year Celebrate Thanksgiving Like A Mensch. Or if you’d like to rekindle your Gratitude to become more open to Generosity, try the 15 Minute Gratitude Challenge. 
Photo by Priscilla Du Preez on Unsplash

Filed Under: Featured, Generosity Tagged With: generosity, gratitude, mussar thanksgiving

A Generosity Mussar Practice I learned By Donating My Computer

June 10, 2019 By Greg Marcus 4 Comments

generosity mussar practice
A small and obvious action led to something deep that was hidden. Photo by Ben Kolde on Unsplash

After an amazing year of working on the shadow-side soul traits, my Mussar practice was in a rut. My focus was on learning Hebrew, looking ahead to Rabbinical school, and taking care of my daughters who had their wisdom teeth out in successive weeks. And don’t get me started on the ups and downs of the Warriors quest to win another championship.

None of which actually preclude my Mussar practice, although each of them are feeding my Evil Inclination, to distract me from what is important. To be clear, Mussar is never far from my thoughts, but I haven’t been systematically working on a particular soul trait, with a mantra, mindful action and journaling. Hence, my Mussar practice is in a rut.

That started to change when I decided to donate an old computer to clear out space on my cluttered so-called desk. I erased the memory, re-installed the operating system, and posted on Nextdoor for ideas on where to donate it.

I was shocked at how many people wanted it. I got the expected suggestions for schools to give to college bound kids, and non-profits. I did not expect a personal request from a young adult working full time and going to school. Or this note

“…we have a single mom who works for us as a cleaner & has just started her 1st set of classes to become a preschool teacher.  A MacBook Pro would be an AMAZING gift to her.  She is hard working & wants to better her life so her kids have a better life too.”

The person I choose is local, working, in school, and is always posting on Nextdoor offering to housesit or to feed pets. She wrote to me, “Words can’t describe how grateful I feel reading your message this morning.”

After I read this email, I felt profoundly different, in a way that can be explained by the Mussar masters. Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto wrote in Path of the Just “One who perceives a quickening of his outer movements… conditions himself to experience a flaming inner movement.” Or put another way, taking action changes our inner world.

Teachings about the soul trait of Generosity go even further. One of the spiritual traps we can fall into is a “stopped up heart.” This is a barrier that prevents us from connecting with others. Perhaps it is a result of past hurts, or just something that has happened as external events or internal habits distract us from what is important. Whatever the cause, giving to others is a way of opening the heart.

This is exactly where I was with my Mussar rut – too focused on tasks and my own stuff, and not enough on the external world. Giving away the computer to a specific person opened my heart, and got me out of my rut. Which brings us to a Generosity Mussar Practice:

**************Here’s the Generosity Mussar Practice***********
Give something other than money. If you are able to give financially, that is wonderful. What else can you add to the gift? If you are giving money to a homeless person, give attention and dignity, by making eye contact and saying hello.
If you work all the time, give some undivided attention to someone you love.
And if you have an old computer you aren’t using, give it away.
*****************************************************************
The point of a Generosity Mussar practice is to open the heart.

Once you’ve successfully done an act of generosity, do another one the next day, and again the next. Can you do one extra generous thing seven days in a row?

I guarantee that if you try to push yourself, you’ll find the voice of resistance in your head. In his book Everyday Holiness,  Alan Morinis points out that this voice can take many forms, like rationalization, or fear. By stepping into this resistance, we can learn more about what holds us back. Each time we give anyway, we open the heart just a bit more.

In invite you to join me in doing one generous thing every day for the next seven days. I’ll start my day with the mantra “Open your hand to open your heart,” and will journal about my experiences at night.

If you’d like to join me, or have another thought, please comment below. It doesn’t matter when you start. Generosity can and will open your heart to the wonderful souls you share the earth with.

I’ll update my generosity practice every day on Facebook. Please come join and follow along.

Filed Under: Featured Tagged With: computer donation, generosity, generosity mussar practice, nedivut mussar

Search

Recent Posts

  • When 9/11 and Elul Collide: A Mussar Reflection on Life and Death
  • Psalm 27 2025 Workshop Materials
  • Finding Awe During Life Transitions: A Mussar Perspective
  • Five Mussar Traits to Help You Move
  • Finding Trust in a Troubled World: A Mussar Perspective on Worry

LINKS

  • Judaism Unbound
  • The Mussar Institute
  • Center For Contemporary Mussar
  • Character Day
  • Kirva
  • Rabbi Chaim Safren video blog

Copyright © 2025 · Greg Marcus | Site-AskMePc | Log in